Past Drafts

A review of draft classes versus historical slot expectations (based on selection No.), as well as their actual results. Drafts are shown here once players have completed their Age-24 seasons. Over these drafts, the top 5 ranked F by NHLdx in each draft have outscored the actual selections by 9% in the NHL in their peak years, and the top 20 by 6% (outperforming the top 20 in 5 of the 6 seasons presented, with the 6th season underperforming by 2%).

 
2020
Entry Draft

Virtually
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Alexis Lafreniere1New York Rangers83-
 Quinton Byfield2Los Angeles Kings85-
 Tim Stutzle3Ottawa Senators56-
 Lucas Raymond4Detroit Red Wings32-
 Alexander Holtz7New Jersey Devils47-
 Jack Quinn8Buffalo Sabres39-
 Marco Rossi9Minnesota Wild52-
 Cole Perfetti10Winnipeg Jets55-
 Anton Lundell12Florida Panthers48-
 Seth Jarvis13Carolina Hurricanes60-
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Sam Colangelo36Anaheim Ducks41-
 Brendan Brisson29Vegas Golden Knights40-
 Jacob Perreault27Anaheim Ducks36-
 Connor Zary24Calgary Flames35-
 Mavrik Bourque30Dallas Stars31-
 Tyson Foerster23Philadelphia Flyers30-
 
 COMMENTS
A very deep draft class. Those outside of the Top 10 were still taken in the first round (and Sam Colangelo at the beginning of the second). Lucas Raymond's scouting reports talked about his high skill levels; he just hasn't translated those into points so far in his career.
 



 
2019
Entry Draft

Rogers Arena — Vancouver, BC
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Jack Hughes1New Jersey Devils72-
 Kaapo Kakko2New York Rangers67-
 Kirby Dach3Chicago Blackhawks33-
 Alex Turcotte5Los Angeles Kings49-
 Dylan Cozens7Buffalo Sabres30-
 Trevor Zegras9Anaheim Ducks41-
 Vasili Podkolzin10Vancouver Canucks11-
 Matthew Boldy12Minnesota Wild35-
 Cole Caufield15Montreal Canadiens27-
 Alex Newhook16Colorado Avalanche21-
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Arthur Kaliyev33Los Angeles Kings41-
 Antti Saarela123Chicago Blackhawks35-
 Bobby Brink34Philadelphia Flyers34-
 
 COMMENTS
Vasili Podkolzin looks like a big swing at No. 10, but Russians are tricky to predict.
 



 
2018
Entry Draft

American Airlines Center — Dallas, TX
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Andrei Svechnikov2Carolina Hurricanes71-
 Jesperi Kotkaniemi3Montreal Canadiens43-
 Brady Tkachuk4Ottawa Senators36-
 Barrett Hayton5Arizona Coyotes22-
 Filip Zadina6Detroit Red Wings34-
 Vitali Kravtsov9New York Rangers21-
 Oliver Wahlstrom11New York Islanders44-
 Ty Dellandrea13Dallas Stars20-
 Joel Farabee14Philadelphia Flyers32-
 Grigori Denisenko15Florida Panthers12-
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Filip Hallander58Pittsburgh Penguins50-
 Jacob Olofsson56Montreal Canadiens46-
 Isac Lundestrom23Anaheim Ducks35-
 Jack Drury42Carolina Hurricanes31-
 
 COMMENTS
Grigori Denisenko was playing in the KHL as an 18-year-old. He didn't put up big numbers. As a 19-year-old he didn't improve on his numbers much. He's one to watch, but the trend isn't good so far.
 



 
2017
Entry Draft

United Center — Chicago, IL
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Nico Hischier1New Jersey Devils52-
 Nolan Patrick2Philadelphia Flyers34-
 Elias Pettersson5Vancouver Canucks85-
 Cody Glass6Vegas Golden Knights40-
 Lias Andersson7New York Rangers44-
 Casey Mittelstadt8Buffalo Sabres41-
 Michael Rasmussen9Detroit Red Wings30-
 Owen Tippett10Florida Panthers34-
 Gabriel Vilardi11Los Angeles Kings35-
 Martin Necas12Carolina Hurricanes25-
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Nick Suzuki13Vegas Golden Knights47-
 Jesper Boqvist36New Jersey Devils37-
 
 COMMENTS
Elias Pettersson was taken after 4 other players, despite elite numbers. Nick Suzuki was on the board until Pick 13. Some things don't make sense.
 



 
2016
Entry Draft

First Niagara Center — Buffalo, NY
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Auston Matthews1Toronto Maple Leafs76-
 Patrik Laine2Winnipeg Jets59-
 Pierre-Luc Dubois3Columbus Blue Jackets60-
 Jesse Puljujarvi4Edmonton Oilers46-
 Matthew Tkachuk6Calgary Flames41-
 Clayton Keller7Arizona Coyotes53-
 Alexander Nylander8Buffalo Sabres31-
 Tyson Jost10Colorado Avalanche24-
 Logan Brown11Ottawa Senators26-
 Michael McLeod12New Jersey Devils22-
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Jonathan Dahlen42Ottawa Senators52-
 Luke Kunin15Minnesota Wild43-
 Tage Thompson26St. Louis Blues38-
 Kieffer Bellows19New York Islanders36-
 Jesper Bratt162New Jersey Devils36-
 Oskar Steen165Boston Bruins35-
 Cam Morrison40Colorado Avalanche34-
 Carl Grundstrom57Toronto Maple Leafs33-
 Adam Mascherin38Florida Panthers30-
 
 COMMENTS
Things look pretty good so far for the Top 10 forwards taken. The model was off on Matthew Tkachuk's point totals (he's reasonably close to a point per game in his NHL career), but still had him as the 8th best forward in the draft.

Jesse Puljujarvi is a big wild card here as he's stuck in Edmonton Oilers/trade request purgatory.

This group is just entering the Age 22-24 window for our performance measurements.
 



 
2015
Entry Draft

BB&T Center — Sunrise, FL
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Connor McDavid1Edmonton Oilers120123
 Jack Eichel2Buffalo Sabres8590
 Dylan Strome3Arizona Coyotes6557
 Mitchell Marner4Toronto Maple Leafs7893
 Pavel Zacha6New Jersey Devils2337
 Timo Meier9San Jose Sharks3063
 Mikko Rantanen10Colorado Avalanche3890
 Lawson Crouse11Florida Panthers2027
 Denis Guryanov12Dallas Stars1831
 Jake DeBrusk14Boston Bruins2047
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Kyle Connor17Winnipeg Jets5574
 Robin Kovacs62New York Rangers480
 Brock Boeser23Vancouver Canucks3865
 Sebastian Aho35Carolina Hurricanes3781
 Anthony Beauvillier28New York Islanders3636
 Jeremy Bracco61Toronto Maple Leafs350
 Roope Hintz49Dallas Stars3138
 Jack Roslovic25Winnipeg Jets3029
 
 COMMENTS
Connor McDavid is pretty good at scoring. He's the only player to hit 100 NHLdx in a season, and he cleared that threshold quite easily.

The Boston Bruins had 3 straight picks starting at No. 14. Jake DeBrusk looks to have been a good choice. Should they have taken Connor and Barzal? There were plenty of other excellent options as well. Zenyshyn and DeBrusk had a *combined* NHLdx of 36. If selecting just forwards, for NHLdx it would've been Connor, Robin Kovacs (oops), and Brock Boeser.

Kirill Kaprizov, Travis Konecny, Daniel Sprong, Barzal, and Colin White are next on the list just below 30 NHLdx. Incredible depth to this draft class.

The Bruins picks aren't the only things that seemed obvious - Pavel Zacha and Lawson Crouse never should've gone that high considering the options.

Jeremy Bracco is at 113 points in 119 GP in the AHL over the last 2 seasons. He still hasn't gotten a shot in the NHL. Selfishly, the model thinks he deserves one.

Robin Kovacs hasn't excelled anywhere outside of the Allsvenskan, and seems to have established himself as just a middle-6 forward in the SHL. There was obviously something in the scouting report that contradicted his stats and knocked him down to the 3rd round.
 



 
2014
Entry Draft

Wells Fargo Center — Philadelphia, PA
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Sam Reinhart2Buffalo Sabres5958
 Leon Draisaitl3Edmonton Oilers75101
 Sam Bennett4Calgary Flames5526
 Michael Dal Colle5New York Islanders4816
 Jake Virtanen6Vancouver Canucks2631
 William Nylander8Toronto Maple Leafs3459
 Nikolaj Ehlers9Winnipeg Jets4259
 Nick Ritchie10Anaheim Ducks3435
 Kevin Fiala11Nashville Predators7250
 Brendan Perlini12Phoenix Coyotes3124
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 David Pastrnak25Boston Bruins6596
 Robby Fabbri21St. Louis Blues4433
 Sonny Milano16Columbus Blue Jackets4233
 Nick Schmaltz20Chicago Blackhawks3653
 Nikolay Goldobin27San Jose Sharks3532
 Josh Ho-Sang28New York Islanders3135
 
 COMMENTS
Draisaitl, Fiala, Pastrnak at 1, 2, 3. Would you take that over what actually happened?

The actual Top 10 averaged 46.2 points/82 GP. The model's Top 10 averaged 52.8 points/82 GP. That's a pretty significant improvement.

Josh Ho-Sang should probably be in the NHL.
 



 
2013
Entry Draft

Prudential Center — Newark, NJ
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Nathan MacKinnon1Colorado Avalanche8485
 Aleksander Barkov2Florida Panthers7983
 Jonathan Drouin3Tampa Bay Lightning7553
 Elias Lindholm5Carolina Hurricanes6258
 Sean Monahan6Calgary Flames3571
 Bo Horvat9Vancouver Canucks2256
 Valeri Nichushkin10Dallas Stars3514
 Max Domi12Phoenix Coyotes3556
 Alexander Wennberg14Columbus Blue Jackets6144
 Curtis Lazar17Ottawa Senators1512
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Artturi Lehkonen55Montreal Canadiens5729
 Nic Petan43Winnipeg Jets3916
 Jacob de la Rose34Montreal Canadiens3113
 Taylor Cammarata76New York Islanders310
 
 COMMENTS
The 2013 Draft was admittedly a mixed showing by the model. While it did show a 13% overall improvement in point output in ranking the top 20 forwards vs. the actual top 20 drafted, it didn't fare well in the 5-15 range.

Monahan and Horvat are interesting cases. Neither hit the 80-point mark in juniors, but made the jump to the NHL before they turned 20. Looking deeper, Monahan had great underlying numbers, with a EVGF%Rel of over 12 (the 67s were terrible - they won 12 games that year), while Horvat struggled in comparison to his teammates (-10% EVGF%Rel; in +/- he was +3; his teammate Max Domi was +30), so there's no singular answer to their immediate success.

Nichushkin's numbers would look better if he hadn't left for the KHL in his peak years. He's at 29 PTS/82 GP in his career.

Curtis Lazar as a bust was entirely predictable. Sorry, Ottawa. It just wasn't a strong year for the WHL - Nic Petan, who had a much stronger case, with 120 points for Portland, has never managed to secure a regular NHL roster spot.

Taylor Cammarata, even when adjusting for his height (5'7"), looked solid. It wasn't immediately apparent he'd be a bust, as after great numbers in the USHL in his draft year, he followed with a strong freshman season in the NCAA with Minnesota. The model definitely thinks that a 3rd-round selection was a worthy risk.
 



 
2012
Entry Draft

Consol Energy Center — Pittsburgh, PA
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Nail Yakupov1Edmonton Oilers5424
 Filip Forsberg11Washington Capitals4066
 Mikhail Grigorenko12Buffalo Sabres3327
 Radek Faksa13Dallas Stars2531
 Zemgus Girgensons14Buffalo Sabres3618
 Tom Wilson16Washington Capitals1126
 Tomas Hertl17San Jose Sharks4344
 Teuvo Teravainen18Chicago Blackhawks3947
 Scott Laughton20Philadelphia Flyers1822
 Mark Jankowski21Calgary Flames2428
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Pontus Aberg37Nashville Predators3121
 
 COMMENTS
A strongly above-average performance by the model, at 20%+ improvement vs. the top 5 and top 20 selected.

Questions as to whether Yakupov was the right pick at No. 1 were legitimate in a sense. His numbers weren't strong vs. historical precedents at No. 1, but he was still the top F by the model.

Some may say Filip Forsberg should have obviously been the top F chosen, but his numbers in the Allsvenskan were pedestrian (17 points in 43 GP; for comparison, Alexander Wennberg nearly doubled that the next season).

Teams definitely missed out on Hertl and Teravainen - the model liked them both. Buffalo would probably want a re-do.

*Note that we don't include Alex Galchenyuk (No. 3 overall) here - he missed all but 2 games in the 2011-12 season. Extrapolating his numbers, he would likely be in the 45-point range.
 



 
2011
Entry Draft

Xcel Energy Center — St. Paul, MN
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Ryan Nugent-Hopkins1Edmonton Oilers5651
 Gabriel Landeskog2Colorado Avalanche3551
 Jonathan Huberdeau3Florida Panthers4661
 Ryan Strome5New York Islanders4540
 Mika Zibanejad6Ottawa Senators3750
 Mark Scheifele7Winnipeg Jets2467
 Sean Couturier8Philadelphia Flyers4142
 Sven Bartschi13Calgary Flames2836
 J.T. Miller15New York Rangers2645
 Joel Armia16Buffalo Sabres5123
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Johnny Gaudreau104Calgary Flames3172
 Matt Puempel24Ottawa Senators3015
 
 COMMENTS
Scheifele was a surprise to the model, but there was a good reason for that (similar to Ryan Johansen's poor projection in 2010) - he was only 6th in scoring among 2011 draft-eligible players in the OHL.

Armia was a surprise in the other direction - he put up excellent numbers (29 PTS in 48 GP) for an 18-year-old in the Liiga. That said, he might just be a late bloomer - over the past 2 seasons he's increased his production to 38 points/82 GP.

Johnny Hockey should have been drafted higher than No. 104. He wasn't predicted as near-elite, but NHLdx had him ranked No. 8 among F.
 



 
2010
Entry Draft

Staples Center — Los Angeles, CA
 
 TOP 10 F SELECTED NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Taylor Hall1Edmonton Oilers6771
 Tyler Seguin2Boston Bruins6486
 Ryan Johansen4Columbus Blue Jackets2565
 Nino Niederreiter5New York Islanders3039
 Brett Connolly6Tampa Bay Lightning3125
 Jeff Skinner7Carolina Hurricanes5048
 Alexander Burmistrov8Atlanta Thrashers1921
 Mikael Granlund9Minnesota Wild7447
 Jaden Schwartz14St. Louis Blues6361
 Vladimir Tarasenko16St. Louis Blues5870
 
 OTHER F at 30 NHLdx NHLdxActual
Selected  Draft Team at 18 PTS/82
 Jordan Weal70Los Angeles Kings310
 
 COMMENTS
The model had no definitive choice in the Taylor/Tyler debate. Seguin was over a point/GP in from age 22-24, but over their entire careers both are in the low 70s/82 GP.

The model wasn't a fan of Johansen, but with good reason - he was 4th in scoring among 2010 draft-eligible players in the WHL.

Weal eventually did make it as an NHL regular, but didn't score his first point until his Age 25 season (he registered 0 points in 14 GP the year before), which means his production technically falls outside of our definition of "peak." He's put up 26 points/82 games so far in his NHL career.

Great job by St. Louis.